
Four more Randolph Scott Westerns today, all are from Budd Boetticher The Collector's Choice. It's a five film collection and I'd already seen The Tall T from The Randolph Scott Round-UP collection. After seeing that film I ordered the BBTCC from eBay as there are commentaries and interviews that are worth having. The copies on Amazon are much more expensive, and from Amazon Partners, so I'm thinking it's out of print. I had found The Randolph Scott Round-Up from Mill Creek for cheap and I'll keep it, there's a film on there I don't have, The Lawless Street, which was directed by another director. The Mill Creek set puts the 6 films on two discs, with no extras, while the five films in the BBTCC set are on their own discs. Those five films are the core of the 7 Westerns Boetticher made with Randolph Scott. The only ones missing are Seven Men From Now and Westbound. Both are available and I put them on my wish list.

Decision At Sundown 1957 Charles G Lang wrote the screenplay and it was based on a 1955 novel, of the same name, by Vernon L Fluharty. Never heard of either of the but I see Lang wrote another of the Scott/Boetticher films and an episode of Cheyenne, The High Chaparral and Perry Mason and a couple of Bonanza.
Randolph comes to the small town of Sundown looking to kill a man named Tate. He's played by John Carroll who was Zorro in the 1937 Zorro Rides Again. I have seen that but I don't remember him any. Tate had had an affair with Randolph's wife while he was off fighting the Civil War. She committed suicide before Randolph returned and he blames Tate. Randolph's pal, played by Noah Beery Jr, tries to tell him she wasn't a good woman and Tate was just one of many but Randolph won't listen.


Things turn tense when Randolph crashes Tate's wedding and tells him he wants to kill him. Much of the rest of the movie has Randolph holed up in a stable. The situation is taken advantage of by townspeople who want Tate gone but were too weak to do anything about it. It ends poorly for some but the lady is saved from marrying the baddie. That's always nice. I enjoyed it quite a bit. There's a good cast and it's a nice modern story that's still a good Western. There's an interesting but short interview with Taylor Hackford and the original theatrical trailer.

Buchanan Rides Alone 1958 Charles G Lang writes the screenplay and he adapts a novel by Jonas Ward. I read Ward wrote 30 Western and Crime novels that I haven't heard of or read, he died at 38 in 1960.
Randolph rides across the US Mexican border into the border town of Agry Town. It's a crooked place run by the Agry family. Randolph helps a Mexican man called Juan who comes over the border to kill the Agry nephew for attacking his sister. They both wind up in jail but Randolph gets cleared of the charges.

The family falls apart when Juan's father offers 30 horses for his return alive. The head Agry wants $50,000 and the other Agry's go after the money themselves. There's plenty of action and a good story. I liked the cast, Craig Stevens, Berry Kelly, Tol Avery, Peter Whitney, Joe De Santis, and L Q Jones. All in all, a winner for me. Taylor Hackford talks about the film in a short interview and there's the original theatrical trailer.

Ride Lonesome 1959 This one is written by Burt Kennedy. Burt wrote 30 movies and directed 35 in his career. I liked his 1976 version of Jim Thompson's The Killer Inside Of Me with Stacy Keach. He also directed the James Gardner comedies Support Your Local Sheriff and Support You Local Gunfighter. He died in 2001 after 45 years in the business.

Randolph is a bounty hunter, he catches James Best, who had killed a man in Santa Cruz. James says his brother, played by Lee Van Cleef, will come looking for him. Pernell Roberts and James Coburn are waiting at a stagecoach station with Karen Steele. Her hubby, the station manager, is out looking for his horses. The local Indians attack and the group takes off. Randolph wants to return James for the reward and it turns out Pernell and Coburn want the man, they can trade him for amnesty for their past crimes.

It all comes to ahead at that dead tree. You'll be surprised at what comes out. It's a good story, sadder than some, but there's a good ending. It was James Coburn's first film and he was especially entertaining. This film has a nice audio commentary by film historian Jeremy Arnold, a short interview with Martin Scorsese and the original theatrical trailer.

Comanche Station 1960 Burt Kennedy wrote this film too.

Randolph buys a white women from a Comanche Chief for some goods and a rifle. Heading for her home they encounter Claude Akins, Skip Homeier and Richard Rust. Randolph knows Claude from the Army but they aren't friends by any stretch. The men band together for safety because of the active Comanches.

Claude eventually tells Randolph he's going to take the woman away from him. There's a $5000 reward for her, dead or alive, and Claude is thinking dead is easier to deal with. His two henchmen aren't too keen on killing a woman. It causes a rift and things so south for the baddies. Especially since Randolph is so good with a gun.
Another good story and great cast. I know I'm going to want to watch these all over again. There's a good audio commentary by Taylor Hackford, Clint Eastwood talks about the film in a short interview and there's the original theatrical trailer.